Can the right diet really cure all our health problems? The concept of 'food as medicine' has gained traction, but is it a viable solution? While it's true that a poor diet can contribute to chronic health issues, simply telling people to 'eat real food' doesn't address the systemic barriers that make healthy eating difficult. The issue lies in the individual responsibility placed on consumers, rather than improving the food environment. This approach fails to consider the influence of commercial determinants of health, such as the abundance of ultra-processed foods in grocery stores and the addictive nature of fats and sugars. The 'food is medicine' message, as promoted by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., risks being misinterpreted as a call to avoid pharmaceuticals in favor of nutrient-rich foods. This could lead to people bypassing conventional medical care, which is not the intended goal. A real 'food is medicine' strategy should focus on creating 'food oases' in 'food swamps', making healthy food more accessible and affordable. This includes supporting efforts to limit the purchase of unhealthy foods with food stamps and improving food regulations to address the root causes of chronic disease. While some experts support these measures, others advocate for a ban on the sale of harmful ultra-processed foods to minors. Ultimately, a balanced approach is needed, combining healthy eating advice with modern medicine to address both individual and societal health issues.